CO129-113 - MacDonnell - 1866 [5-6] — Page 421

(Copy)

19

_Report_

420

I am of opinion upon the whole

arcumstances of this

Amhailier hour

case that the Chinese

have given auch proof of the

frisoner's Guilt as entitles them to his Rendition under the Preaty. The endence of the two Witriker for the prosecution reas

cross-

by the nof.

substantially misharten by

neamination which they underwent from the laut, from myself and from Mr

Henry

Shemy C. Coldwell a solicitor who defended the prisoner.

The midence in support of the

alili is very wear. Bort Witnesses calleds n behalf of the prisoner

are Shimlast

people and might so easily be corroborated